Articles

We should be allowed to kill you, or euthanasia explained to those who want it

Perfectly legal, perfectly clean, perfectly consented to. That is exactly the problem. "You're against euthanasia? Come on — who are you to stop someone who is suffering from choosing their own death?" Nobody. I am nobody, and that is precisely the problem, and precisely why I a…

Read more →

Why Lucifer is not Lucifer, or the Devil reduced to a family communication problem

The Prince of Darkness is working on himself. His shadow already knows where this ends. Almost ten years ago, on a train. I was coming back from a tabletop role-playing session1 with one of the players: a declared atheist, a good-natured man, solid in biology, curious about ever…

Read more →

The burning void of death, or why the anguished must not be stopped from their anguish, or why anguish is proof that God is

A man screams his anguish into the night: "My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?" (Matthew 27:46)... or God is dead? Is it not the same thing, for the sensible man? "Show me your glory." Moses, Exodus 33:18. "You cannot see my face, for no one may see me and live." YHWH, Exo…

Read more →

The burden of proof doesn't exist, or how to dodge a debate while looking smart

Two men at a table, each pointing a finger at the other. Between them, an open book that nobody is looking at. The entire "burden of proof" in one image. "The burden of proof is on you!" There. The debate is over. My interlocutor has just uttered the magic formula. He can now cr…

Read more →

"Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence," or the art of saying nothing with authority

A man searching for his keys under a streetlight, in a circle of light. Far away in the darkness, the keys gleam. The entire epistemology of the slogan in one image. There are phrases that function like passwords. You utter them, and doors open: the door of intellectual respecta…

Read more →

The rational panic, or how to lose a fight against your own shadow

Crumpled scraps of paper, and gigantic shadows. The entire history of contemporary anti-theism in one image. "What if I'm wrong? What if, somewhere, in some corner of the multiverse, there's an argument so devastating that it would pulverize in one blow all of classical metaphys…

Read more →

Requiem for New Atheism, or the eulogy of an enemy we didn't deserve

An empty gothic cathedral, an open coffin in the middle of the nave, and a pot-bellied man slumped on his phone. The entirety of New Atheism summarized in one image. I have a confession to make, and it will surprise you: I miss New Atheism. Not its conclusions, obviously. Not it…

Read more →

Why their arguments don't work, or how to pull on strings that are already dangling

The strings are dangling. You just have to pull. "How do you write stuff like that without tripping over your own feet? The debates on evil, the Euthyphro dilemma, the First Cause, theistic evolution, the ambient anti-metaphysical mood... it makes my head spin. They're not right…

Read more →

What even is a final cause, or why your morning hot chocolate refutes materialism

A rubber duck sitting in a cup of hot chocolate, surrounded by a sketch of Aristotle's four causes. Because if an acorn can become an oak, surely it can become a duck. Apparently not. "But what's the point of a final cause?" Again? Not that the question is stupid (it isn't), but…

Read more →

Why I am a Darwinist AND a Catholic, or how Darwin naturalized God without knowing it

A praying chimp in a Gothic cathedral. Monod would call it absurd. Thomas would say the chimp is right. Darwin would note the chimp was selected for it. I recently listened to a debate featuring Kenneth Raymond Miller AGAINST creationism. For those who don't know him, Miller is …

Read more →